The turing machine is a mathematical abstraction of a concrete physical process. We know that quantum computing does not violate the church turing thesis, which concernscomputability, however we have reason to suspect. Do you believe quantum computers can violate the extended. The churchturing thesis stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. In computer science and quantum physics, the church turing deutsch principle ctd principle is a stronger, physical form of the church turing thesis formulated by david deutsch in 1985. This thesis says that any physically computable function can be computed on a turing machine with at most a polynomial increase in the running time. The churchturing thesis and turing machines allowed researchers in the 40s and 50s to create a theory of computability what is computable and what not. Quantum information science is an inherently interdisciplinary field physics. Every quantum mechanical computational process can be simulated ef. The churchturing thesis as a guiding principle for physics. Received july 1984 abstract it is argued that underlying the church turing hypothesis there is an implicit physical assertion. The physical churchturing thesis and the principles of quantum theory article pdf available in international journal of foundations of computer science 235. So the original aka weak churchturing thesis is not affected by quantum computation. Here, this assertion is presented explicitly as a physical principle.
Pdf the physical churchturing thesis and the principles of. As was emphasized by deutsch, quantum computation shatters complexity theory, but is innocuous to computability theory. Quantum computing would be a likely counterexample, if in fact it can be instantiated, but are there possibilities weaker than quantum that would be counterexamples as well. There exists a growing literature on the socalled physical church turing thesis in a relativistic spacetime setting. The physical church turing thesis is the conjecture that no computing device that is physically realizable even in principle can exceed the computational barriers of a turing machine. The evidence for the turing model to be the correct model seemed so convincing that a term, churchturing thesis, evolved into existence over the years to express that conviction. The church turing thesis is the assertion that this set s contains every function whose.
It asserts that any reasonable model of computation can be ef. So the original akaweak church turing thesis is not affected by quantum computation. This thesis asserts that any reasonable computational model can be. We will see that quantum computers are exponentially more powerful than classical computers. The basic principle behind quantum computation is that quantum properties can be used to represent data and perform operations on it. Consequently, the quantum complexitytheoretic churchturing thesis states. In fact, in terms of complexity theory, we even have bqp pspace. Turings expression for turing machines were first proposed by alan turing, in an attempt to give a mathematically precise definition of algorithm or. Speci cally, the strong church turing thesis held that any reasonable computing model could simulate any other with modest overhead. Churchturing thesis seems to be false, with quantum computing standing as a. Computability, complexity and quantum computing4 105.
A stronger version of the church turing thesis has been phrased as. A turing machine starts with an input on the left end of the tape. A quantum turing machine qtm or universal quantum computer is an abstract machine used to model the effects of a quantum computer. The replacement predicates that turing and church proposed were, on the face of it, very different from one another. Efficiently all physical theories can be simulated by tms efficiently. Quantum computer simple english wikipedia, the free. A function on the natural numbers can be calculated by an e ective method if and only if it is computable by a turing machine. In computability theory, the churchturing thesis also known as computability thesis, the turingchurch thesis, the churchturing conjecture, churchs thesis, churchs conjecture, and turings thesis is a hypothesis about the nature of computable functions. The churchturing thesisct is the belief that, in the standard turing machine model, one has found the most general concept for. Yet nielsen and others have shown how quantum theory as it stands could breach the physical church turing thesis. Computability and complexity the churchturing thesis.
Jan 07, 2014 so now you understand the churchturing thesis. Following the development of quantum computers, a question has arisen regarding the relation between the basis of the classical theory of computation and the quantum theory. As an aside, whether or not p and np describe the same set of problems is one of the most important open questions in computer science. Any physical computing device can be simulated by a turing machine in a number of steps polynomial in the resources used by the computing device. Before quantum computers, all known realistic computing devices satisfied the extended churchturing thesis, 1,2 which said that the power of any computing device built could be only polynomially faster than a. Sep 06, 2016 church turing thesis a turing machine is an abstract representation of a computing device. Topological quantum computing tqc solves the fragility of the qubits at the. A quantuminformationtheoretic complement to a general.
It is argued that underlying the churchturing hypothesis there is an implicit physical assertion. The churchturing thesis is a connection between the mathematical notion of an algorithm and the intuitive notion of what is thought of as an algorithm. From churchturing thesis to qubits find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. In computer science and quantum physics, the churchturingdeutsch principle ctd principle is a stronger, physical form of the churchturing thesis formulated by david deutsch in 1985. There are various equivalent formulations of the churchturing thesis. The role of interference and entanglement in quantum computing. Quantum computation and extended churchturing thesis 0. Even rnore so, this applies to the weak church turing thesis, often referred to as cookkarp thesis, putting into question the robustness of the notion of tractability or polynomial ti1ne complexity class with respect to variations of reasonable models of computation. From church turing thesis to qubits find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. A common one is that every effective computation can be carried out by a turing machine. However, these predicates turned out to be equivalent, in the sense that each picks out the same set, call it s, of mathematical functions.
It provides a simple model that captures all of the power of quantum computationthat is, any quantum algorithm can be expressed formally as a particular quantum turing machine. Indeed, this notion of quantum computers being devices that can ef. Before quantum computers, all known realistic computing devices satisfied the extended church turing thesis, 1,2 which said that the power of any computing device built could be only polynomially faster than a. The physical churchturing thesis and the principles of quantum. This led to a folk thesis, which we call the polynomial churchs thesis, whose origins appear to be impossible to pin down, but which has nevertheless been widely referred to in the literature. Relativity turns out to still be compatible with this hypothesis, but as we will see, quantum mechanics is not. A theoretical model is the quantum turing machine, also known as the universal quantum computer.
A turing machine reads and writes symbols on an in. Quantum theory, the churchturing principle and the. In statements of this thesis, the turing machine is sometimes augmented with a random number generator, as it has not yet been determined whether there are. There is a unique quantum model of computing or a physical quantum field theory can be efficiently simulated by quantum computers.
However, the churchturing thesis is not really quite equivalent to the turing principle. One particular famous contemporary case is quantum computing. So the original akaweak churchturing thesis is not affected by quantum computation. Quantum theory, the church turing principle and the universal quantum computer david deutsch appeared in proceedings of the royal society of london a 400, pp. Churchturing thesis revisited 1 the churchturing thesis formerly known as churchs thesis says that every intuitively computable function is computable by some turing machine. A turing machine moves its readwrite head in both directions.
There are con icting points of view about the churchturing thesis. Quantum theory, the churchturing principle and the universal quantum computer david deutsch appeared in proceedings of the royal society of london a 400, pp. Therefore, the physical churchturing thesis is a strong statement of belief about the limits of both physics and computation. Church turing thesis wikimili, the best wikipedia reader. Quantum computing stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. It is more like a computer hardware than a computer software. It states that a function on the natural numbers can be calculated by an effective method if and only if it is computable by a. The existence of standard quantum computers does not disprove the churchturing thesis. Pdf on oct 1, 2016, shankhadip kundu and others published quantum computation.
Quantum computation umd department of computer science. Quantum theory, the churchturing principle and the universal. So in a future post ill develop what the difference is and what its philosophical ramifications are. A turing machine outputs accept or reject by entering its accepting or rejecting states respectively. The churchturing thesis is often misunderstood, particularly in recent writing in the philosophy of mind. The churchturing thesis in a quantum world kent school of. Pdf the physical churchturing thesis and the principles. It states that a function on the natural numbers is computable by a human being following an algorithm, ignoring resource. Feb 08, 2011 the physical churchturing thesis and the principles of quantum theory article pdf available in international journal of foundations of computer science 235 february 2011 with 1 reads. Quantum computerscanbe simulated by classical computers with exponential slowdown. So the original aka weak church turing thesis is not affected by quantum computation. Eugene eberbach and peter wegner claim that the churchturing thesis is sometimes interpreted too broadly, stating the broader assertion that algorithms precisely capture what. Here i argue against deutschs claim that a physical principle, the turing principle, underlies the famous churchturing hypothesis. The principle states that a universal computing device can simulate every physical process.
1390 1159 1263 375 1300 493 952 1388 824 607 645 1002 905 1097 17 1164 895 405 676 213 1041 1389 639 904 1033 706 514 150 852 738 911 513 503