The legal system of south africa still symbolises this divide. This collection of essays looks beyond pragmatic, situational jockeying, and also. Moving beyond the hierarchical approach to legal pluralism in the south pacific. Legal pluralism and empires, 15001850, edited by lauren benton. Ross legal pluralism and empires, 15001850 new york university press, 20. Contributors scholars lauren benton is professor of history and af. Legal pluralism and development policy scholars and practitioners in dialogue 1 caroline sage and michael woolcock part i. Towards a feminist theory of legal pluralism in africa, 8 soc. A jurisprudence of law beyond borders cambridge university press 2012. Summer 2004 international legal pluralism 967 courts and arbitral tribunals actively applying international law is far greater than it has ever been. Pluralism, in richard ross and lauren benton, eds, legal pluralism and empires nyu, 20, 10942. Paper presented at the symposium new perspectives in legal pluralism, newberry library, chicago, april 16. Legal pluralism and empires, 15001850, edited by lauren. Problems of sovereignty in early modern europe erasmo castellani outside portfolio field 1.
Ross the subject of empires is both very old and very new. The inevitable legal pluralism within universal harmonization. Jurisdiction, sovereignty, and political imagination in the early modern world pp. Berman, paul schiff gw law the george washington university. The most recent literature on imperial history and legal pluralism, exemplified by the ambitious work of lauren benton, has moved our understanding beyond both formal legal pluralism with neatly stacked legal systems, as well as a binary opposition between state and nonstate law. Law and geography in european empires, 14001900 cambridge universityh press, 2010. The age of constitutions in the americas must include latin america and the caribbean. It is with deep regret that the executive body has made the hard decision today to postpone the 2020 course and conference to 2021, again to be held in brisbane. In a world in which plural legal orders were the norm, multicentric jurisdictional orders created continuities across diverse regions and polities. Definitions of legal pluralism abound but diverge for discussion, see. Reconstructing early modern notions of legal pluralism by richard. This issue lies at the very core of legal pluralism.
Some have viewed this expansion of international tribunals and the increasing frequency of international claims in national courts as indicative of the fragmentation of the international legal. Abolition and legal pluralism in the british empire. Ross, lauren benton published by nyu press ross, richard j. Legal regimes in world history, 14001900 lauren benton, nelson o tyrone jr professor of history and professor of law dean college of arts and science lauren benton cambridge university press, 2002 history 285 pages. More specifically, they and the assembled authors wish to front legal pluralism as an essential lens on the history of empires, and by extension global history, across. Jurisdiction, sovereignty, and political imagination in the early modern world 1 empires and legal pluralism. Here is the abstract, followed by some comments from yours truly. The experience that things dont add up, that coherence fails, that incommensurability must be acknowledged. Jurisdiction, sovereignty, and political imagination in the early modern world, in legal pluralism and empire, eds. Moreover, lauren benton, who has introduced this term into legal historical debates, recently has come to favor the designation jurisdictional pluralism bentonross 20. She is the author of numerous books and articles on law, global history, and economic development, including a search for sovereignty.
As john lovett points out, much of the recent scholarship on progressive property draws on united states cases. This dissertation offers critical insights into issues of access to justice by tracing the gains and losses in meaning across multiple accounts of a dispute that began with adivasi protests against hindustan coca. Legal pluralism and empires, 15001850 new york university press, 20 editor, with richard ross. Legal pluralism as a colonial project in bengal and west africa. Colonialism shaped a framework for the politics of legal pluralism. The british empire and the origins of international law, 18001850. Sep 03, 2007 it has been a major topic in legal anthropology and legal sociology for about two decades, and is now getting attention in comparative law and international law. Benton and ford find that empire framed visions of global order much more than references to natural law principles or to vattelian visions of sovereignty, in dimensions far beyond the articulation of a standard of civilization from which certain. Given the renewed focus on legal pluralism, scholars from many different fieldslaw, international relations, critical geography, law and society, colonial theory, cosmopolitanism, and religionshould cheer legal pluralism and empires, 15001850, as a truly significant contribution to our work. Dissolution of marriage, legal pluralism and womens rights in francophone west africa 5 thanks this regional research project received the scientific and financial support of the danish institute for human rights dihr in copenhagen, in partnership with the institute for human rights and peace ihrp at the cheikh anta diop university in dakar.
To speak of religious pluralism is often simply to state the obvious. Law and geography in european empires, 1400 1900 cambridge, cambridge uersitvni y ess,pr 2010. Legal pluralism and empires, 15001850 is a collection of essays that attempts to reorient our understanding of european colonialism in the early modern era. Law and geography in modern european empires, 14001900 cambridge university press 2010. Dissolution of marriage, legal pluralism and womens. Cosmopolitan pluralism is presented as a conceptual framework for. Focusing on colonial legal politics and the interrelation of local cultural contests and institutional change, it uses case studies to trace a shift in plural legal ordersfrom the multicentric law of early empires to the statecentered law of the colonial and postcolonial world. Tomlins and mann, the many legalities of early america oi, 2001 lauren benton and richard ross, legal pluralism and empires. Lauren benton born 1956 is an american historian known for her works on the history of empires, colonial and imperial law, and the history of international law. Constitution making continued questions of empire, jurisdiction, sover. Legal pluralism is not a fact about the world it is a professional experience. Dec 04, 2015 with this impressive collection of studies, lauren benton and richard ross aim to contribute to a new narrative of world history that places empires at its center p. Finally, part iii will articulate an approach to contemporary legal pluralism that avoids the conceptual problems suffered by most current approaches, while framing the salient features of legal pluralism. According to the introductory essay by lauren benton and richard ross, it poses new questions.
Despite historians once frequent mining of anthropology for methodological insights, legal pluralism has only recently begun to gather momentum among historians. Lauren benton is professor of history and affiliated professor of law at new york university. This book advances a new perspective in world history, arguing that institutions and cultureand not just the global economyserve as important elements of international order. For the record i have my doubts about legal pluralism as it can sometimes be interpreted by anarchocapitalists. Piracy and the origins of ocean regionalism, in comparative stud ies in society and history, 47, 2005, 4, pp. This recent convergence on the notion of legal pluralism is fueled by the apparent multiplicity of legal orders, from the local level to global level. An old narrative of a transition from empires to nationstates has now given way to an emphasis on the centrality and persistence of empires in world. Yet, in the words of leonards and randeraad, the degree of success enjoyed by transnational ideas and arrangements is a surprisingly neglected. Convicts, slaves, and the remaking of plural legal order in the british empire commentator. Space, jurisdiction, law, legal pluralism, empire, political. Legal regimes in world history, 14001900 2002, which. Usually it means something more, that is, that we should be appreciative and respectful toward all of them instead of supposing that one is true and good and the others false and evil. Historical research represents our richest vein of information about the workings of legal pluralism. Legal pluralism has vast policy and governance implications.
Legal pluralism and empires, 15001850 richard jeffrey ross, lauren a. Historical perspectives on legal pluralism chapter 1. An introduction to colonial and neocolonial laws clarendon press 1975. Significantly, sojourners and settlers only rarely positioned themselves outside. Those working in gender studies were particular beneficiaries. Before the long nineteenth century, all legal orders featured jurisdictional tensions without strong claims of legal hegemony by states. Jul 05, 2016 legal pluralism and empires, 15001850 ed. Professor of history and professor of law at vanderbilt university. Hist 715 sp 2018 vast early america final karin wulf. Yet, in the words of leonards and randeraad, the degree of success enjoyed by transnational ideas and arrangements is a surprisingly neglected theme in the literature on transnationalism p. Cambridge core legal history law and colonial cultures by lauren benton. Revising the constitutional convention harvard, 2015 ann twinam, purchasing whiteness. Various initial works by lauren benton, elizabeth dale, richard j.
Dissolution of marriage, legal pluralism and womens rights. Ross, and others in the area coalesce to suggest this approach. The traditional concept of legal pluralism, developed in legal anthropology and sociology to analyze overlapping normative orders within societies, became popular in the 1970s and 1980s. Legal pluralism and empires, 15001850 new york university press, 20 editor, with richard ross this melancholy labyrinth. Law and geography in european empires, 14001900 2010. Historical perspectives on legal pluralism springerlink. Empires and legal pluralism jurisdiction, sovereignty, and political imagination in the early modern world lauren benton and richard j. Project muse legal pluralism and empires, 15001850. Lauren benton is a comparative and world historian whose research focuses on law in european empires, the history of international law, and atlantic world history. The journal of legal pluralism and unofficial law, vol. Others strengthen the idea of hybridity and analyze jurisdictional pluralism from this perspective heirbautdonlan 2015.
Legal pluralism and empires, 15001850 benton, lauren, ross, richard j. In developing countries, for instance, nonstate justice systems often handle most disputes and retain substantial autonomy and authority. This recent convergence on the notion of legal pluralism is fueled by the apparent multiplicity of. Studies in comparative world history includes bibliographical references and index. It has been a major topic in legal anthropology and legal sociology for about two decades, and is now getting attention in comparative law and international law. With this impressive collection of studies, lauren benton and richard ross aim to contribute to a new narrative of world history that places empires at its center p. Article information, pdf download for beyond legal pluralism. Legal pluralism and empires, 15001850 richard jeffrey ross. Benton and ford find that empire framed visions of global order much more than references to natural law principles or to vattelian visions of sovereignty, in dimensions far beyond the articulation of a standard of civilization from which certain colonial peripheries were tidily excluded at 21. For a study of legal pluralism within a global framework, see. Historical perspectives on legal pluralism colonialcorpus.
At the risk of typologizing the typologies, let me offer three modes of experiencing legal pluralism. Although the notion of legal pluralism is gaining popularity across a range of academic disciplines, from its very inception it has been plagued by a fundamental conceptual problem the difficulty of defining law for the purposes of legal pluralism. Lauren benton faculty law school vanderbilt university. The next biennial course and conference of the commission on legal pluralism were scheduled to take place in july 2020, in brisbane, australia on july 10 to and 15 to 17 respectively. For example, members of cultural and religious communities previously forced to live together as a result of apartheid observe certain aspects of their own laws which are generally not recognised by our law. Lauren benton and richard ross have been leading exponents of legal pluralism, and have coedited this volume of papers from the 2010 symposium on comparative early modern legal. Throughout the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, nonmuslim ottomans paid large sums to acquire access to european law. Legal pluralism and empires, 15001850 richard jeffrey. Laura benton and richard j ross eds, legal pluralism and empires, 1500 1850 nw e nw ky, oer kyuorersitvni y ess,pr 20. Lauren benton is a comparative and world historian whose research focuses on law. Benton this wideranging volume advances our understanding of law and empire in the early modern world. Published by anu press the australian national university acton act 2601, australia email. History, law, and the problem of imperial sovereignty lauren benton is professor of history at new york university. Legal pluralism occurs when two or more legal orders exert control.
1399 122 948 661 1266 404 219 1316 92 108 1311 1140 1172 1136 282 807 899 592 1187 1317 1489 974 1304 202 1250 387 291 1090